Article From: 12/21/2012 Production Machining, Rick Crabtree, Product and Application Specialist - CBN/PCD from Sandvik Coromant
Click Image to Enlarge
The Xcel insert concept is particularly suited to the demands of productive hard part turning, when surface finish and security, as well as roughing with high material removal rates, are required.
With the maximum chip thickness as the basis for feed rate, comparing a standard nose radius insert with Xcel indicates the capacity for higher feed rates available. The thinner chip generated by a straight edge at a small entering angle provides “room” for productivity. This concept is also used in milling, where high feed cutters provide high machining capacity.
Hard part turning is an alternative and complementary machining method to grinding of hardened components, typically within the 55 to 65 HRc range. Modern CBN grades have contributed substantially to strong, durable tools, and today`s insert-technology has also provided cutting edges that raise both productivity and finishing capabilities.
Machining components in their hardened condition, either through-hardened or case-hardened, have many advantages in helping to achieve better accuracy more efficiently. As it has gained interest and become more common, hard part turning has driven several recent tooling developments. An obstacle that was overcome some years ago was that of suitable machine tools, and although some lathes are more suited than others for the stability-demanding setups necessary for this area, most modern CNC lathes are capable.
Hard part turning has its own set of demands in that cutting forces and pressure on the tool are more severe than they would be with materials in their green condition. Also, the hard workpiece material is abrasive, so more wear and heat are generated. There are, however, tool materials well-suited to this area—primarily cubic boron nitride (CBN), which is second in hardness only to diamond. Today, a range of excellent insert grades, with CBN particles as the main constituents, is available for hard part turning.
Insert Efficiency Here
Because feed rate ultimately determines the amount of time a job will take, improving feed rate can result in considerable savings of production hours and costs. New developments in cutting tools are improving efficiencies—sometimes as dramatically as tripling the feed rate. “Feed rate is where we will really improve things,” explains Martin Saunders, an application specialist in turning. He cites two examples of manufacturers who made overnight productivity improvements of 116 percent and 322 percent, respectively, simply by switching to a different insert for their turning projects in CNC lathes. No new machinery or methods were required.
“What is very positive about the insert these companies use,” Mr. Saunders says, “is the higher feed rate still achieves very good surface finishes. A feed of 0.3 mm/rev (0.12 ipr) generates a surface finish of less than Rz 1 micron (Ra 0.14 microinch). Even a feed of 0.5 mm/rev (0.20 ipr) will give less than Rz 5 microns (Ra 0.7 microinch). To put this into context, when common surface finishes for turned parts are Rz 6.3 microns (Ra 0.88 microinch), feeds of 60 to 65 percent slower would be required if a standard insert with a radius-based nose-corner was used.”
The insert that is providing productivity improvements on this scale, bringing a generational boost to hard part turning performance, is the Xcel-type insert from Sandvik Coromant. Sacha Kotarac, an application specialist with experience in problem solving for engineering companies, lets the surface finish determine his application of the insert. “I introduce Xcel as much as possible for finish-turning as long as the surface finish demands are achievable,” he says. “And I also use the feed-rate capability as much as possible for roughing operations. As long as I have sufficient clearance against any shoulder, the inserts can be applied with feeds up to 0.5 mm/rev (0.02 ipr), when normal stability is there. We are talking about rates twice that of wiper inserts. The Xcel and wiper inserts should also be seen to complement each other, often providing a stable operation with predictable results.
“One manufacturing company we worked with was planning to replace its grinding machines with lathes for hard part turning. In this case, we saw the best solution was to use Xcel for roughing, followed by Sandvik Coromant’s WG-type wiper designed for semi-finishing operations. We ran a trial on their machines and presented them with the results and machining times,” Mr. Kotarac adds. “The outcome was that the customer thought it worthwhile to change all of the component drawings to introduce sufficient clearance to take advantage of the Xcel capability and tasked us with fully equipping the machine. We recommended a feed rate of 0.4 mm/rev (0.16 ipr) for roughing with Xcel, generating a surface finish of Ra 0.5 micron (20 microinches). For the WG insert, the feed rate is 0.33 mm/rev (0.12 ipr) generating a finish of Ra 0.42 micron (17 microinches).”
For Best Results
Stability is a success factor for all CBN-insert applications, but the Xcel insert emphasizes it. To make sure conditions are optimum for success with this insert, the length-to-diameter ratio should be kept to less than 4 to 1. This is not to say it will not work at a higher ratio, but 4 to 1 or less provides the absolute best conditions.
The standard round-nose insert generates the lowest cutting forces, but the feed rate is strictly limited to the relationship between the nose-radius and the surface finish. Sandvik Coromant’s wiper insert with WH geometry gives a high surface finish at a higher feed, with a relatively low stability requirement. Next, the wiper insert with the WG geometry gives an even better surface finish at an even higher feed, but it needs more stability. When the Xcel insert can be used, it gives high surface finish at high feeds, but with low stability requirements. Even at low feed rates, this insert will generate very good surface finishes. The feed rate relationship with surface finish is always the key parameter when the focus is on minimizing cutting times.
With a small entry angle of 10 degrees, the depth of cut is limited—but it would be limited in hard part turning anyway. With conventional round-nose inserts, the chip thickness varies along the edge. With the Xcel, however, there is a uniform, thin chip, allowing for the high feed rates. A main part of the innovation is the way the straight part of the edge blends in with the specially developed wiper, which forms the transition to the back clearance part of the edge.
While the depth of cut capability of the Xcel insert is limited by the straight edge, normal depth requirements in hard part turning are usually about 0.20 mm (0.008 inch). The capability of the insert is best used when one-pass operations can be applied, using the entire cutting edge with depth-of-cut capacity and the highest feed that the surface finish limit will allow. For semi-roughing operations, the stability is sometimes the limiting factor.
The insert can improve tool life as well, spreading wear evenly across the edge. A standard round-nose insert experiences more extensive wear at the depth of cut on the cutting edge, limiting durability. The improvement is partly because of reduced temperature generated through the shorter contact time in cut, spread out along the longer straight edge. Consequently, more parts can be machined with Xcel, even at the highly elevated feeds.
Making the Grade
Xcel inserts come in two grades based on cubic boron nitride (CBN). This is a tool material of high hot hardness designed to resist plastic deformation, making it capable of high combinations of feed and cutting speed in hardened materials. Today’s grades also have good toughness for strength and good resistance to withstand thermal shocks. Grades today have a CBN-content of 40 to 65 percent, with a ceramic binder to add the chemical wear resistance needed at high temperatures. These grades are mechanically strong so as to be resistant to abrasive wear. Additionally, there are even higher content CBN grades with metallic binders for more toughness.
Continuous or interrupted cuts make different demands on the cutting tools. To optimize hard part turning operations, it is important to apply the most suitable grade. For continuous-finish turning, especially case-hardened parts needing optimal wear resistance, CB7015 provides a very good combination of high metal removal rates and durability. This performance is based on a fine-grain size in a specially developed ceramic binder, which allows the grade to develop wear slowly, in a controlled manner, along the edge of the Xcel insert. Continuous cuts with or without light intermittence are ideal for this grade.
When intermittent cuts prevail and are heavier, a tougher grade such as CB7025 is the best choice. This grade has the capability to generate high surface finishes when there are interruptions in the surface, such as on gear wheels or slots in shafts or when some instability is present in the setup. It is also a modern fine-grain CBN grade in a ceramic binder developed to have the strength to cope with these types of demands.